While coins in perfect shape often grab the spotlight at auctions, you might be surprised to learn that even circulated quarters—those you get in daily change—can hold unexpected value.
In fact, a few select coins still found in circulation today are worth far more than their face value, even if they show signs of wear. Curious? Let’s explore some valuable quarters hiding in plain sight and how you can spot them.
1. 2019-W and 2020-W West Point Quarters
In a move that thrilled collectors, the U.S. Mint quietly introduced a limited run of quarters from the West Point Mint in 2019 and 2020. These were not exclusive collector coins—they were actually mixed into regular circulation, with only 2 million of each design minted annually.
What makes them special? It’s the tiny “W” mintmark found under “IN GOD WE TRUST” on the obverse. This subtle marking sets them apart from other quarters. Though they’re fairly recent, their scarcity and novelty make them highly collectible. If you find one, keep it—it might be a future classic in the collecting world.
2. 1932-D Washington Quarter
The 1932-D quarter holds a special place in history as part of the first year of the Washington series. Minted in Denver, just 436,800 were made—an extremely low number for any U.S. coin. This rarity boosts its appeal to collectors.
To identify one, check the reverse side just above “ER” in “QUARTER” for the “D” mintmark. Even a worn example graded “1” by PCGS can command around $225. If it’s in near-pristine shape, say AU55, you’re looking at a value of $525 or more. Rare at every grade level, this coin is a major target for serious hobbyists.
3. 1932-S Washington Quarter
Also minted during the Washington quarter’s debut year, the 1932-S is slightly rarer than the Denver version, with only 408,000 minted. It shares a similar placement for the “S” mintmark—right above the “ER” in “QUARTER”—making it fairly easy to check.
Despite its age, about 40,000 of these are believed to exist today. In poor condition, you might still fetch $85 for it. If you’re lucky enough to have one in AU58 condition, its value can soar above $360. With numbers this low, even worn coins are worth getting graded and appraised.
4. 1937-S Washington Quarter
While the 1937-S isn’t as rare as the 1932 issues, it remains a standout due to its lower mintage compared to other coins from the same era. Collectors often look for coins from this time, and this one still offers impressive value for those who find it.
A quarter with a grade as low as “3” could still net you around $8. Move up to EF45, and the price jumps to approximately $100. If you’ve got one that’s nearly uncirculated, the value could top $165. It’s a solid find for anyone who enjoys spotting overlooked collectibles.
5. 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter – Extra Leaf (Low Variety)
Among the 50 State Quarters, Wisconsin’s 2004-D edition has a fascinating twist—literally. A die error resulted in some coins showing an extra leaf near the corn stalk on the reverse. The “Low Leaf” version features a small leaf pointing downward toward the cheese wheel.
Though over 227 million were minted in total, only a fraction contain this error. Even in VF30 condition, these can be worth around $38. A better-preserved example at VF55 might go for $80. It’s a quirky variation with a fun backstory and strong appeal among error-coin collectors.
6. 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter – Extra Leaf (High Variety)
Closely related to the “Low Leaf” version, the “High Leaf” error is considered even rarer. In this variation, the added leaf points upward, blending slightly behind the existing corn husk—a detail that adds intrigue and value.
Collectors are willing to pay a premium for this rarer type. A VF30 coin might earn you $45, while one in VF45 condition or better could be worth upwards of $75. These subtle die differences can have a big impact on value, especially when they spark interest in modern error coins.
Final Thoughts: Hidden Treasures in Your Pocket Change
You don’t have to be a professional coin collector to stumble upon a valuable quarter. Sometimes, rare coins with historical significance or unexpected mint errors find their way into everyday transactions. Whether you’re hunting for a low-mintage piece or an unusual mintmark, the thrill of discovery is half the fun. A quick look through your change might just uncover something extraordinary.
If you come across a coin that seems special, take time to research it—or better yet, get it examined by a professional. That seemingly ordinary quarter could be hiding an extraordinary story and a surprising price tag.
FAQs
How can I tell if my quarter is from the West Point Mint?
Check the obverse side for a small “W” mintmark, located just below the phrase “IN GOD WE TRUST.”
Are circulated rare quarters still valuable?
Yes, coins like the 1932-D or 1932-S can be worth hundreds, even if they’ve been heavily used, depending on their condition.
What is the difference between the Extra Leaf High and Low Wisconsin quarters?
The Low Leaf points downward toward the cheese wheel, while the High Leaf extends upward behind the corn stalk.
Should I get my rare quarter professionally graded?
If you believe the coin is rare and in good shape, professional grading—though it costs around $40—can boost its appeal and resale value.
